Lyrics
The Unofficial Sequel to White Roses
Oh, you made me a song?
That’s so thoughtful.
I figured I’d return the favor…
Although I might have a few corrections.
You had a girl, you had a guy,
You had another alibi.
A different number, a different name,
But somehow I was supposed to play the same game.
You called me yours when it was convenient,
Kept me hidden, kept me guessing.
I was looking for a little affection,
You were running a full-blown dating convention.
You had more options than a dating site,
More plot twists than a Friday night.
You wanted loyalty, honesty and trust,
Funny how those rules only applied to us.
Oh, my always and forever,
Unless somebody else came through.
You had men and women on rotation,
But somehow I was supposed to be true.
I was your secret, your backup plan,
Your convenient little maybe.
You called me your one and only,
But apparently, you were everybody’s baby.
At Phoenix House, I thought we were healing,
Didn’t know what else you were concealing.
While I was trying to figure out us,
You had another relationship to discuss.
Down at Ronkonkoma, what a beautiful view,
Except I spent half the time waiting for you.
You’d disappear with somebody new,
Guess the lake had more than one attraction for you.
Remember those letters I wrote from my heart?
The ones you never bothered to start?
Now you’ve written a song about what they meant,
That’s some interesting literary development.
And sushi night, what a beautiful scene,
You accused me of flirting with the waitress in between.
You walked right out, made quite a display,
While your own little roster was having a field day.
Oh, my always and forever,
That’s a funny way to show you care.
You were everywhere but beside me,
Yet now you claim you were always there.
You had a whole cast of characters,
I was just trying to make it through.
You wrote a song about our love story,
But apparently forgot the other people in it, too.
You sang about Noah and milestones,
Like you were there watching him grow.
But you missed the birthdays, the moments,
The little things you’ll never know.
You weren’t there for the memories,
You weren’t there to share the day.
But now you’re singing like you helped raise him,
That’s quite a rewrite, I have to say.
White roses? Never happened.
Christmas morning? Wrong again.
Phoenix House? Check the guest list.
Lake Ronkonkoma? Ask where you’d been.
The letters? Never read them.
The waitress? You walked away.
The milestones? You missed them.
But now you’ve got so much to say.
You made yourself the leading lady,
In a story you barely played.
Congratulations on the soundtrack,
It’s the best fiction you’ve ever made.
Oh, my always and forever,
What a masterpiece of make-believe.
You had a revolving door of lovers,
While I was trying to believe.
Keep the roses, keep the soundtrack,
Keep the memories you’ve rearranged.
You didn’t write our love story,
You just changed the names!
And one last thing…
Did you make a different version for the guys?
And the other girls?
Just wondering who gets the deluxe edition.
Because apparently…
Everybody was part of our love story except me.
This song was made with StarSinger
Describe a person or a moment in a few words. StarSinger writes the lyrics and sings it.
FAQ
Who made "Everybody but me"?
"Everybody but me" was made by @eager_ocelot_59 on Star Singer, where anyone can write and sing an original song with AI.
What genre is Everybody but me?
Everybody but me is Pop.
Can I listen to "Everybody but me" for free?
Yes. "Everybody but me" streams free on Star Singer — no subscription required. You can also make your own: one AI song a day is free, extra songs with a lyric video are $1.99, a lip-synced music video starring you is $19.99, and cinematic videos start at $2.99.
Can I create my own AI song?
Yes. Star Singer lets you create AI-generated songs and music videos. Clone your voice, pick any style, and generate original music. Listening is free and unlimited, and one song a day is free to make — no subscription.
Thanks — this has been sent to our review team.